Feb
02

Invention and Innovation

Vaclav Smil, prolific author of several best selling book, published "Invention and Innovation: A Brief History of Hype and Failure" (2023) with MIT Press. The book presents a three-part approach to assessing invention and innovation, which examines: (1) inventions that works but we later learned caused harm - leaded gasoline, DDT, CFCs; (2) Inventions we expected to scale but did not - airships, nuclear fission, supersonic flight; (3) inventions that did materialize at all - hyperloop, nitrogen-fixing cereals, controlled nuclear fusion. The framework is useful for thinking about invention and innovation. The chapters are relatively basic overviews of the nine innovation types. The book is accessible and readable, which helps to reach a broad audience. Book ends with some reality checks on innovations, in particular with regard to energy and climate change. A few notes:

"I will adopt a more general approach to inventive failures by focusing on the fact that the flow of fundamental and enormously successful inventions that have created modern civilization during the past 150 years has been accompanied by a frustrating lack of progress in many key areas, as well as on the innovations that, to put it charitably, did not do as well as initially expected. In this book I examine three notable categories of these innovation failures: unfulfilled promises, disappointments, and eventual rejections." (p. 11-12)

"The history of tetraethyl lead is, in the first place, the story of failed public health measures: if the known risks had been taken into account, there would not have been, decades later, a failed invention and the need to ban the compound's use. CFCs and DDT carry different, much more sobering but also expected lessons: human interventions in Earth's envi- ronment often carry delayed, complex risks, so far removed from the initial concern and so far beyond the readily conceivable complications that only time and the accumulation of events will make us aware of those unexpected but highly consequential impacts." (p. 23)

  305 Hits
Oct
05

Numbers Don't Lie

Compiling five years of weekly essays, "Numbers Don't Lie: 71 Things You Need to Know About the World" (2020) is one of Vaclav Smil's many books. The author is prolific and influential (apparently Bill Gates has read all of his nearly 40 books, and Gates promoted this book in particular). He is also the academic many dream to be - apparently attending only one faculty meeting over decades of being a professor - his "reclusive" approach was tolerated by the University of Manitoba so long as he kept publishing popular books and taught classes. That is more on the author as usual because this book is disappointing, with a wide ranging / sometimes random set of topics handled with OpEd level of detail. The value of this collection, of already published short articles, is unclear (but Vaclav sells far more books than I do...). If you are new to Vaclac Smil, I'd probably start elsewhere.  

  481 Hits
Subscribe to receive new blog posts via email